Compare and contrast the arrangement of elements in Mendeleev’s Period Table and the Modern Periodic Table.
Compare and contrast the arrangement of elements in Mendeleev’s Period Table and the Modern Periodic Table.
The main points of distinction between Mendeleev’s Periodic Table and Modern Periodic Table are:
Mendeleev’s Periodic Table:
1. It regards the atomic masses of the elements as the basis of classification.
2. No separate positions or slots have been allotted to the isotopes of an element since they have different atomic masses.
3. No justification is made for placing hydrogen in group IA along with alkali metals.
4. Except for the elements, in group VIII, the remaining groups have been divided with sub-groups A and B.
5. Position of certain elements based on their atomic masses are misfits. For example, the element cobalt (atomic mass = 58.9) has been placed ahead of nickel (atomic mass = 58.7)
6. Electronic configurations and properties of the elements cannot be predicted from their positions in the table.
7. It is not very systematic and is difficult to remember.
Modern Periodic Table:
1. It regards the atomic number of the elements as the basis of classification.
2. There is no need for separate slots for the isotopes since they have the same atomic numbers.
3. Justification has been made for placing hydrogen along with alkali metals in group 1 since both hydrogen and alkali metals have one valence electron.
4. There are no subgroups and all groups are independent in nature.
5. Modern Periodic Table is free from such anomalies. The element cobalt is placed before nickel since its atomic number (27) is more than that of nickel (28).
6. Both electronic configurations and certain properties of the elements can be predicted from their positions in the periodic table.
7. It is quite systematic and is easy to remember.
-
A non-metal X which is the largest constituent of air combines with hydrogen when heated in the presence of iron as catalyst to form a gas Y. When gas Y is treated with sulphuric acid, it forms a compound Z which is used as a chemical fertiliser.
3 years ago
-
The non-metal A is an important constituent of our food and most of the fuels around us. A forms two oxides B and C. Oxide B is poisonous whereas oxide C causes global warming.
3 years ago
-
Write the names and symbols of two very reactive metals belonging to group 1 of the periodic table. Explain by drawing electronic structure, how either one of the two metals reacts with a halogen.
3 years ago
-
Atoms of eight elements A, B, C, D, E, F, G, and H have the same number of electron shells but different number of electrons in their outermost shells. It was found that elements A and G combine to form an ionic compound. This ionic compound is added...
3 years ago
-
Find the neutral atom in the periodic table which has the same number of electrons as K^+ and Cl. What is this number?
3 years ago
- 321 Forums
- 27.3 K Topics
- 53.8 K Posts
- 0 Online
- 12.4 K Members